Tuesday, November 12, 2019
English coursework â⬠Hamlet refers to Claudius Essay
Hamlet refers to Claudius as a ââ¬Å"Remorseless, treacherous, lecherous, kindles villain! â⬠How far do you share his view? A villain is usually driven by something, usually power or money. Claudius has two of the greatest motives, power and lust. ââ¬Å"My crown, mine own ambition, and my queenâ⬠Claudius lists the things he committed the murder for. Crown signalising power comes before queen, Gertrude. Villainââ¬â¢s motives are sometimes unimportant. Iago has no real motive to completely ruin peopleââ¬â¢s lives but does it because he enjoys it, only an extremely evil villain would gain pleasure through the suffering of others. Claudius has far greater motives. Firstly he would gain great power, a thing desired by many. He would also then have Gertrude whom he does care for and wants. Claudius has a tremendous talent at controlling and influencing people, whether it is through their views or their actions. Claudius switches Laertesââ¬â¢ anger from himself to Hamlet with ease ââ¬Å"I am guiltless of your fatherââ¬â¢s deathâ⬠to do that you would have to be a very convincing liar and be good at deceiving. Claudius then invites in a mad Ophelia to deceive Laertes, and to make him believe Hamlet is the culprit. Claudiusââ¬â¢ manipulation of Hamletââ¬â¢s feelings is apparent early on in the play showing his true self to be a sly, cunning and extremely clever man. All these qualities are shown in his opening speech as he addresses the court; Claudius speaks about the issue of his brotherââ¬â¢s death, ââ¬Å"our dear brotherââ¬â¢s death, the memory be greenâ⬠then, in a few sentences, moves on t the subject of his marriage, ââ¬Å"Therefore our sometimes sister, now our queenâ⬠Claudius addresses his authority by referring to his wife as Queen letting all know that he is King. This is a very efficient and to the point statement showing Claudiusââ¬â¢ intelligence, a characteristic common in the best and most evil villains. Claudius changes the subject ââ¬Å"For all, our thanksâ⬠again it is simple and with minimum fuss. Claudius moves on to the next subject; a possible attack from a neighbouring country. He makes light of the situation by belittling the opposition; ââ¬Å"Young Fortinbras, Holding a weak supposal of our worthâ⬠he calls the King young, immediately bringing to mind the thought of a child, not a very intimidating opponent. He also says ââ¬Ëourââ¬â¢; gently letting the court he is the new King. ââ¬Å"So much for himâ⬠these are the final words on the subject. Claudius has covered the death of his brother, his marriage with his former sister and a possible invasion and left the court laughing, smiling and joking. He is extremely clever to have done all this without arousing any suspicion and win over the court days after the death of the former King. Claudius ability to manipulate is obvious. Claudiusââ¬â¢ talent for influencing and manipulating people continues throughout he play, showing a theme common in many villains. In Star Wars, The Emperor is a villain who desires power and is truly evil. Claudius desires power and kills his brother to have it. The Emperor shares the ability to manipulate others, instead of killing a foe he would try to influence them to join him. However the greatest evil quality that The Emperor and Claudius have in common is their emotionless reaction to the suffering they cause to others. When Claudius drives Ophelia mad through ignoring her and abusing her he is then comfortable to use her to manipulate Laertes. The Emperor shows no concern when he destroys a planet and itââ¬â¢s population. Claudius also puts people down, an already depressed Hamlet is one of his targets. ââ¬Å"ââ¬ËTis sweet and commendableâ⬠Claudius ignores how Hamlet is feeling about the death of his father. Saying someoneââ¬â¢s mourning is ââ¬Ëcommendableââ¬â¢ is insulting. He continues to put Hamlet down by again ignoring how Hamlet feels and telling him to cheer up, ââ¬Å"ââ¬ËTis fault to heaven, A fault against the dead, a fault to natureâ⬠Claudius continues to repeat the word fault making Hamlet feel his mourning is wrong. Claudius has good qualities in him that are unusual in villains. He makes an attempt to repent ââ¬Å"My stronger guilt defeats my strong intentâ⬠but he feels he cannot be forgiven because his sin is too great. Villains like Iago form Othello and Ming the Merciless both show no conscience at all. Claudius is also spiritual in the way that he understands God and knows what sin is. Spirituality isnââ¬â¢t something a truly evil villain has. Claudius shows caring and feels affection for Gertrude ââ¬Å"She is so conjunctive to my life and soulâ⬠an incredible thing to say about someone, he shows a love for Gertrude. ââ¬Å"O, my offence is rank, it smells to heavenâ⬠Claudius knows that the things he has done are absolutely awful. He uses a disgusting word to describe his actions, the word rank. A villain of real evil wouldnââ¬â¢t have such a conscience. This shows Claudius not to be evil at his core. Claudius does not fully repent. Because he knows that he doesnââ¬â¢t really mean his apology, ââ¬Å"Words without thoughts never to heaven goâ⬠Claudius is not an evil character. He does disgraceful things and harms people but he does not gain pleasure from hurting people, something truly evil. He does the evil acts because of the results, in his case power. Claudiusââ¬â¢ deliberate ignorance of emotion and ability to manipulate shows him to be disgusting and harmful. Claudius is a treacherous, lecherous, kindles villain but not remorseless. Although he did not repent because of his greed he tried to and it is because of this he is not an evil person. Claudius is however an awful person who deserves no sympathy. Hamletââ¬â¢s opinion of Claudius isnââ¬â¢t far from the truth.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.